The main message delivered by this MS is twofold: firstly, the description of a semi-empirical method of the evaluation of survival probabilities, and secondly, its application to the particularly nontrivial case of broad resonances. A realistic parametrization of pion–pion elastic scattering data is used to show that in the traditional classification of the decay into exponential, oscillatory transition and power-law regions the first two may even be absent. This is the conclusion confirming the consistency of the apparently controveresial assignment of this type of decay to the so called $\sigma$ meson. MR2718338 Kelkar, N. G.; Nowakowski, M. No classical limit of quantum decay for broad states. J. Phys. A 43 (2010), no. 38, 385308, 9 pp. 81U05